UN Wants United States to Give Its Land Back to Indians

The UN wants America to give its land back to the Indians.


More reason to cut funds to this idiot America-hating organization.

The Guardian reported:

A United Nations investigator probing discrimination against Native Americans has called on the US government to return some of the land stolen from Indian tribes as a step toward combatting continuing and systemic racial discrimination.

James Anaya, the UN special rapporteur on the rights of indigenous peoples, said no member of the US Congress would meet him as he investigated the part played by the government in the considerable difficulties faced by Indian tribes.

Anaya said that in nearly two weeks of visiting Indian reservations, indigenous communities in Alaska and Hawaii, and Native Americans now living in cities, he encountered people who suffered a history of dispossession of their lands and resources, the breakdown of their societies and “numerous instances of outright brutality, all grounded on racial discrimination”.

“It’s a racial discrimination that they feel is both systemic and also specific instances of ongoing discrimination that is felt at the individual level,” he said.
Anaya said racism extended from the broad relationship between federal or state governments and tribes down to local issues such as education.

“For example, with the treatment of children in schools both by their peers and by teachers as well as the educational system itself; the way native Americans and indigenous peoples are reflected in the school curriculum and teaching,” he said.

“And discrimination in the sense of the invisibility of Native Americans in the country overall that often is reflected in the popular media. The idea that is often projected through the mainstream media and among public figures that indigenous peoples are either gone or as a group are insignificant or that they’re out to get benefits in terms of handouts, or their communities and cultures are reduced to casinos, which are just flatly wrong.”

Isn’t it also time that western Asia rejoined the Mongol horde?
And, return Spain to the Muslims. No more ham holidays.

Someone needs to ask Elizabeth Warren her thoughts on this.

Get news like this in your Facebook News Feed,
Gateway Pundit

Commenting Policy

Please adhere to our commenting policy to avoid being banned. As a privately owned website, we reserve the right to remove any comment and ban any user at any time.

Comments that contain spam, advertising, vulgarity, threats of violence, racism, anti-Semitism, or personal or abusive attacks on other users may be removed and result in a ban.

Facebook Comments

Disqus Comments

  • Tom in CA

    What are they going to do with it?

  • dba…vagabond trader

    UN should return the real estate it occupies on the upper East Side of Manhattan.

  • Multitude

    What’s most amusing is that this shows extreme cultural ignorance. I can’t believe this poseur analyst claims to have actually visited and studied these cultures, as they would have understood the sedentary lifestyle imposition and conception of “land ownership” upon nomadic cultures such as “native” Americans (actually earlier immigrants, but not the original immigrants by any means) has been most harmful.

    These cultures did not have concepts of land claims; demands to return land are confused and derived from white, western post-imperialist thinking. It’s this very thinking that led to forcing tribes to settle down onto reservations. Furthermore, concepts of tribal territory are also seriously mistaken. Many tribes were at constant war with each other and tribal territories constantly changed. To think of earlier settlers as a singular people aka “natives” is also a fallacy and leads to this kind of orientalist treatment that the UN has constructed.

    The reality is that life is competitive. Islam has kicked others out of territories. China is kicking the crap out of Tibet and the Uyghurs. White European Russians continue to subordinate and eradicate its Siberian nomads. Just ask the French about their love for the Roma, nomadic people that have attempted to roam across Europe. Civilization has been remarkably hard on nomadic peoples, but by no means should one listen to a sedentary-worshipping territorial corrupt nation-state monstrosity like the United Nations for any guidance on providing for the cultural tolerance and continuance of such peoples.

  • lol

    the jew bashing U.N. should shut their pie hole! the hate speech they spew toward Israel is disgusting. the globalist regime currently running the U.S. hangs on every lame word the U.N. says. thankfully no member of congress met with the anti-semitic loons.

  • forest

    Do they want to give East Prussia back to the Germans too?

  • jim m

    Absolutely!! We should evict all of those people from the land they currently occupy and force them to return out to the east coast and take new land and start new lives out there. The best way to make good on an offense from 1 to 2 centuries ago is to create a whole new series of outrages and offenses.

  • As soon as Russia gives the Far East back to the Chinese. And the White South Africans hightail it. And the Chinese give back Tibet. Etc. Etc.

  • journeyman

    Kudos to # 2.


    …as soon as Islam gives back all it’s conquered lands, we Americans will consider their terms.

  • Taqiyyotomist

    Multitude hits it out of the park, again.


  • StrangernFiction

    Sounds good to me. Better they have it than the Feds.

  • SeniorD

    Don’t forget to ask Ward Chamberin for his thoughts.

    Let’s strike a deal with the Useless Nitwits – we’ll start by giving Turtle Bay back to the original owners.

  • lonestar

    They are discriminating against the Karankawa and Towkawa.
    Will the UN give back the billions in aid they kept for their bank accounts instead of actually aiding the poor?
    And about the UN headquarters in NY. What tribe gets that building?

  • lonestar

    Oops, meant Tonkawa.

  • How about the UN giving back the land they occupy in the US?

  • Rachelle

    I am all for returning the plot the UN building stands on.

  • TXPatriot

    So Mexico is now Spain’s? Not sure that’s an improvement, but…

  • Mac in NM

    Are you sure it’s the UN and not Elizabeth Warren’s 1/32 looking for revenge ?

  • paul52

    Human beings have been taking, losing, and retaking lands since before recorded history. I would love to see a presidential candidate seriously vow to get US outta the damn UN if elected. God help the first blue helmets we see on American soil. They will be considered invaders.

  • Jim W

    Just give back what the UN sits on.

  • rg

    It is not right to speak on behalf of the Indian, without being given permission to do so.

  • lynched1

    USA to UN, “Make me”.

  • Pingback: UN Wants United States to Give Its Land Back to Indians|PolitifreakPolitifreak()

  • Since this article was pusblished in the UK’s Guardian, are the Anglo-Saxons going to give their land back to the Welsh?

    ott, there was some stupid show on PBS where some white South African dude was giving the US an attitude problem about OUR history of racism & that somehow we owe white South Africans money because of the trans-Atlantic slave trade (that started before the US was a country & involved other Western countries, like Jamaica, Brazil, etc, besides the US). Since South Africa was a former British colony (where, yes, British people also engaged in the slave trade) why don’t they go to London & demand reparations. Jerk.

  • Mannie

    So let’s give Britain back to the Celts. Send the Saxons back to Saxony, and the Normans back to … Wait, we can’t send them to Normandy, that belongs to the Veneti. While we’re at it, the Germans have to go back east into Eurasia. The Etruscans need to get part of Italy back. Oz and New Zealand go back to the Aborigines. The Blacks and the Whites both must leave South Africa and give it back to The Bushmen.

    Once we’ve done all that, we might as well send the Indians all back to Asia and give America back to the people who lived there before. I believe there are thirty seven of them ( a distinct race) left in Patagonia.

    What the hell were those morons smoking. Whatever it is, I want some. Goooood stuff.

  • Taqiyyotomist
  • juandos

    Well obviously the indians can’t put up that many casinos…

    BTW did anyone else bother to note what this Chris McGreal also has written in the past?

    This man (and I use the term loosely) with the constipated look is obviously a limp wristed weenie…

    Just how blindingly stupid was that article?

    I wonder if the silly SOB would waste time on how the present day Brits should give the isles back to the full blooded Celts assuming they could find any?

  • dba…vagabond trader

    Muzz out of Jerusalem!

  • kathteach

    I say we all decide to give back the UN real estate in New York back to the indigenous peoples and get them the heck out of the USA. Why on earth America has to host to a global body that clearly envies us and wants us to fail – I have no idea.

    #2 – I agree with you. I just thought I’d add to your sentiments.

    UN – get off our American lawn!

  • Economan

    Mexico will now be part o the Axtec Empire and Muslims would have to leave Israel and Africa. Does this mean Asians will leave the American Continent?

  • Redlite

    The Indians that I know of are more dependant on the federal government than Julia would ever dream of being.

    This is pure pie in the sky crap!

    If we did give the land back who would
    harvest the food
    make the beer
    cook meth
    build cars
    and make movies for the Indian population?

    This would be the end for them. They can not exist without the government.

    And just wherE would the other 300 million live?

  • Arch

    If the UN can provide us with valid proof of title to these lands, I’m sure we will compensate them.

    By this logic, should we return Spain and France to the Arabs?

    By this logic, should Europe east of Vienna and all of Asia be ceded to the Mongolians?

    The Americans, Asians and Europeans should file class action lawsuits for Indians introducing us to tobacco causing hundreds of millions of deaths and centuries of addiction.

  • ahem

    Maybe we should all move to Israel.

  • Pingback: UN Wants United States to Give Its Land Back to Indians()

  • Blacque Jacques Shellacque

    More reason to cut funds to this idiot America-hating organization.

    Why stop there?

    We should publicly burn our membership card on the steps of their HQ, then give the organization until the end of the month to move themselves out of the country entirely.

  • The UN should give back some land. I mean that expensive piece of real estate that sits alongside the East River in Manhattan. It is a monument to stupidity and from what I hear cupidity also.

    I know what we can do with its bulding. We can use it as a hotel for the homeless and the infirmed.

    We must transition out of the UN and the sooner the better.

  • Slamerine

    I see the comments about an ignorant story like this and it feels my heart with joy and hope. If the TRUE American people get back to running things WE WILL BE GREAT AGAIN!!!
    How far back does the UN want to go? Why do they get to pick at point things were FAIR? IF you don’t go back to when Heaven and Earth were created then how is anything else truly fair? We fought for this land, just like everybody else THROUGHOUT HISTORY!!!

  • Slamerine

    Sorry, brain fart, meant FILLS MY HEART!!!!

  • Lil Obie

    Remember the “public service” ad on tv in the 60’s & 70’s?
    The one where “Iron Eyes Cody” was looking at pollution and crying?
    Well he was really crying BECAUSE THE BAR WAS CLOSED!

  • Pingback: UN Wants United States to Give Its Land Back to Indians | Born Conservative()

  • 32# Another 4 years of this marxist regime, Israel could be only free country standing…….Hey UN how giving back all millions you have received from America’s taxpayers and posh real estate so you can sit there and judge how evil Americans are….

  • aswipee

    Kill the taxpayer funding and kick the America hating, marxist contolled UN out of the US.

    And sorry, the native American culture was less advanced than the European culture that eventually took control of North America in just about any aspect of competition that mattered regarding survival.

    We’ve done pretty well all things considered. SO, on to the next made up leftie controversy>

  • JDStone

    Since my great grandmother was Creek Indian I suppose the Chumash tribe would kick me out and go live in Georgia.We need to kick the UN out of the US forever!!

  • Alvin

    Jim, I believe that Bill Whittle has an excellent counter to this:



    Does the UN think we need more casinos? Everytime land is given to a tribe, we get another casino!

  • Brae

    The un-UN needs to go to he88. We need to kick their sorry you know what’s out of the country. Go to Somalia~they’ll fit better (or Kenya)

  • stephen E. Morgan

    I’m sure the UN Building sits on former Indian Owned Property. Lets start by handing that back to the Indians.. Hell they can open another Casino!…

  • john b

    Interesting….. I don’t see the name Aztecas in California. La Raza is going to be pissed.

    And: As far as the Shawnee being in Ohio: perhaps someone in the UN should have checked the history of the Shawnee. Harrison did back in the 1800s — enough so he knew not to make treates with them since they were themselves “occupiers” …. after having lost wars to the Upper and Lower Creeks and the Cherokees.

    But I do have a question for the UN: shouldn’t the land in the western states be given back to the Anasazi? Who killed them off?

    thanks, un

  • Babsy

    Duuuuuuuuuuuhhhhhhhhh……. There wouldn’t be a UN without the United States………………..

  • Buffalobob

    Please show me a copy of his expense report. Never mind he works for the UN and they have unlimited funds for bureaucrats to travel the globe in luxury.

  • LOL, yeah that will happen

    How bout we give them the UN building in Manhattan and kill two birds with one stone?

  • Pingback: UN Wants United States to Give Its Land Back to Indians | Liberal Whoppers()

  • tommy mc donnell

    anyone think the UN will ask the muslims to give palestine back to the jews?

  • Redwine

    Muslims out of Africa (particularly northern Africa), the Levant and the Peninsula (and restore the native Christian and Jewish communities throughout), Iran (to Persia of the Zoroastrians), Afghanistan (to the Buddhists), and all of the Indian subcontinent (to the Hindus).

  • burt

    Do we move the Sioux back to Minnesota? They are not from the Black Hills. They murdered their way west.

  • MaryW

    The U.N. building needs to be leveled by a nice big wrecking ball, then shoveled into the Atlantic.

  • Pingback: UN WATCH — Winds Of Jihad By SheikYerMami()

  • atticcellar

    I live near the Onieda Reservation in Wisconsin. Each member recieves 1000’s of dollars from the proceeds of their casinos. They have also recieved cash dispersements from the US Government for decades (at everybody elses expense). If they live on the res they pay no income tax but get benefits and services that they do not pay for. All men are created equal exept indians which are more equal than the rest of us.. If you are a Indian of any tribe you are gauranteed a high paying job with the tribe. If you are not a Indian and work for the tribe you are gaurenteed not to be able to rise higher than the bottom rung as the tribe policy is no non Indian will tell an Indian what to do. I am sick and tired of all of these “minorities” whining that they should get more because of abuses that happened many generations ago while they are given cart blanch rights to discriminate against others.

  • Pingback: Réduit national – UN Wants United States to Give Its Land Back to Indians()

  • Geoff Berry

    Seems like somebody touched nerve.

  • jorgen

    USA out of UN
    UN out of USA

  • jorgen

    Someone needs to ask Elizabeth Warren her thoughts on this.

    She will have a composite view: she will be against it 31/32 and for it 1/32.


    READ the article:
    With Cooperation from Obama
    AND…..Eric Holder.
    OBAMA and HOLDER!!

  • Luke

    I’m a enrolled Oneida. My grandmother was forced into a boarding school and had her culture stripped from her. She never spoke of her native heritage and besides her, my dad and his siblings I know nothing of that side of the family. There are only 3 people left whom used Oneida as a first language. The comments further up about bars, meth and general depravity are ignorent. The people that posted them should be ashamed. While this UN report is definitely pie in the sky it does not give people cart blanche to be racist.

  • Wow, the comments here are terrifying in their stupidity and brutishness. First, the article isn’t referring to making amends for the wholesale destruction of the native American peoples committed by out nation – a fact that is non-controversial and universally acknowledged by all historians. If it were, it would be welcome as Americans have just chosen to ignore the horrific history of our conquest over these peoples. That other nations were formed in equally brutal ways is immaterial, we should be at least interested in understanding and acknowledging our bloody history. If nothing else, perhaps better knowledge of this issue would make right-wingers a little less arrogant when telling the rest of the world how to live.

    But this isn’t even the article’s point. Its point is that there may be current systemic discrimination against Native Americans, and I’m certainly willing to listen to the case being made is. Those of you think this is absurd and find yourself vaguely angry at me might want to note that Glenn Beck points out quite regularly that this chapter of our history is bloody and something to be criticized on a moral basis much more loudly. This isn’t a right-left issue, I’m a libertarian, no leftie.

    If one takes the comments here seriously, it seems you folks believe there is no culpability for our ancestors on this count? That the treatment of Native Americans on the whole isn’t a national shame? Let me point out that I don’t believe in collective guilt, I think it’s immoral as do most thinking people. I will not don the hairshirt due to the actions of our forebears. However, what such episodes remind me of is the ability of humans to remain blind to their own biases in many settings. It’s not something that only white men do, and it doesn’t mean that this country hasn’t been an experiment in perfecting human freedom. But it does mean I’m open to understanding the perspective of a group that has been historically treated as so horribly by our government.

  • MAJ Mike

    Let them attempt to inforce this policy. There will be a rifle behind evey blade of grass and a blue helmet makes a great aim point.

    Besides, have the UN forces stopped raping children yet?

  • Greg

    From conversations I have had with members of the tribe around TUBA City Az., the governmental structure of the reservation is command and control. The tribe leadership tells individuals how much corn they will produce and how much sheep to raise where to live and so on. When one has an excellent corn crop, next year his acreage is reduced and given to others less lucky. As a result there is no reward for excelling at anything. As a result there is a general malaise that affects there total life. For the folks that need visuals checkout the on reservation towns and compare to off reservation. The comparison with housekeeping is enormous.
    The UN and WONWTF actively promote the same reservation behavior, command and control, another term socialism is descriptive also.
    Visit a reservation and talk to the folks, they are nice people living Julie’s storey.

  • Kissmygrits

    Why stop with the US? Canada was stolen from the natives as was Mexico. Then I suppose he could study S. America to see if there was any land stolen from the original settlers. Lands have been taken over by conquering hoards ever since, well since ever. That the UN singled out the US for this study is very telling and we should be telling the UN to quit occupying our lands.

  • avery

    John b 47# this what i been saying all along the mexian never had any claim to any of the western states.

  • I kinda agree! Just California though.

  • greenfairie

    The best way to help American Indians is to get ’em off the reservations.

  • Kick them out

    Give the entire UN back to Belgium or Antwerp and revoke the UN euroweenies US entry visas forever. Problem solved. Oh wait, one more thing. Cancell all US $$ contributions to that hopeless FAIL.

  • averagemelon

    Allow me to announce to the world that I AM A RACIST towards anything with the UN. I believe like thinkers should yank down their pants on the steps of the UN and do what the Ocuppiers do.

  • stuart

    Alvin #43
    I agree with Bill Whittle. He hit the nail on the head precisely.
    Take the Black Hills of Dakota, for instance.
    Do we give it to the Sioux, (Lakota)? They owned it in 1875 when it was invaded by whites.
    Or do we give it to the Kiowa? They claimed it in the late 1700s when it was invaded by Lakota.
    Or do we give it to the Crow who were pushed out by the Kiowa evan earlier and tried to reassert their claim against the Lakota as late as the 1870s?
    Or do we give it to the Shoshone? They and the Crow have a competing claim. Prior to that we have competing claims that span back into antiquity. We don’t even know the names of the tribes that held the Hills in ,say, the year 600 A.D. We refer to them as cultures usually defined by the site that archeologists have discovered, such as clovis or Hopewell.
    The Indians were always confused by the concept that someone could own land. Perhaps they were right. No one “owns” land they simply have a legal permit to occupy it- for a while.

  • solomon hill

    there is something wrong with people who respond with violence and hate.ignorance is the cause.

  • Pingback: U.N. to U.S. : Return Native American Lands | Flopping Aces()

  • Pingback: URL()