Peggy Noonan: An American Crisis in Character

An Obama TSA agent marches away after bringing a passenger to tears at a Midwest airport.

Peggy Noonan’s column today at The Wall Street Journal deals with the modern day American crisis in character.

People in politics talk about the right track/wrong track numbers as an indicator of public mood. This week Gallup had a poll showing only 24% of Americans feel we’re on the right track as a nation. That’s a historic low. Political professionals tend, understandably, to think it’s all about the economy—unemployment, foreclosures, we’re going in the wrong direction. I’ve long thought that public dissatisfaction is about more than the economy, that it’s also about our culture, or rather the flat, brute, highly sexualized thing we call our culture.

Now I’d go a step beyond that. I think more and more people are worried about the American character—who we are and what kind of adults we are raising.

Every story that has broken through the past few weeks has been about who we are as a people. And they are all disturbing.

A tourist is beaten in Baltimore. Young people surround him and laugh. He’s pummeled, stripped and robbed. No one helps. They’re too busy taping it on their smartphones. That’s how we heard their laughter. The video is on YouTube along with the latest McDonalds beat-down and the latest store surveillance tapes of flash mobs. Groups of teenagers swarm into stores, rob everything they can, and run out. The phenomenon is on the rise across the country. Police now have a nickname for it: “flash robs.”

That’s just the young, you say. Juvenile delinquency is as old as history.

Let’s turn to adults.

Also starring on YouTube this week was the sobbing woman. She’s the poor traveler who began to cry great heaving sobs when a Transportation Security Administration agent at the Madison, Wis., airport either patted her down or felt her up, depending on your viewpoint and experience. Jim Hoft of recorded it, and like all the rest of the videos it hurts to watch. When the TSA agent—an adult, a middle aged woman—was done, she just walked away, leaving the passenger alone and uncomforted, like a tourist in Baltimore.

There is the General Services Administration scandal. An agency devoted to efficiency is outed as an agency of mindless bread-and-circuses indulgence. They had a four-day regional conference in Las Vegas, with clowns and mind readers…

Read the rest here.

Get news like this in your Facebook News Feed,
Gateway Pundit

Commenting Policy

Please adhere to our commenting policy to avoid being banned. As a privately owned website, we reserve the right to remove any comment and ban any user at any time.

Comments that contain spam, advertising, vulgarity, threats of violence, racism, anti-Semitism, or personal or abusive attacks on other users may be removed and result in a ban.

Facebook Comments

Disqus Comments

  • P. Aaron

    What”s the matter Peggy? You finally puke up the ‘O’ koolaid?

  • BuddyG

    Reaping the rewards of moral relativism.

  • Don’t you have an important “event” to attend Peggy? Just another daily scrum or two for average americans to deal with down here in the trenches.

  • Really??

    Interesting that NOW at last Ms. Noonan has “seen the light” after all those pro-Obama-the least qualified President ever-columns she wrote beginning in 2008. One of my mentors-an AfiricanAmerican ex Sarge and former Olympic competitor-drilled this bit of observation into my young mush brains: “Sh!t rolls downhill”. Translated:look to the top leadership to know what is coming next.
    Ms. Noonan: you are a day late and a dollar short.

  • Watcher

    As if the so called republican ELITE from the Northeast are any different than the democorrupts. The elites are clueless and scorn we the hoipoiloi, Ms. Noonan included. The political class of all stripes are so isolated from the real country in their northeastern enclaves of privilege that they lost contact with the rest of the country fifty years ago.

  • MAC

    Well let’s see, forty years of “do gooder” government and gyno-marxism. Forty years of single mothers raising boy children into boy men. In our culture the art of manliness and chivalry is dying. No one helped the victim for a basic reason, no one was qualified. In our brave new world only credential teachers know what’s good for children and only the state (police)is qualified to save anyone from a beating. Try to step in and save a victim, you’re mostly going to get arrested.

  • Gary

    If anybody recalls, the libs really descended on that thread last week. Dozens of post repeating only one point: the TSA was started under Bush.
    The thread got up near 300 posts before they finally gave up.

  • ebayer

    See,and after WWII,they said,”It could never happen here”

    It can,it will and it does,happen here.
    Instead of coming from the right,it’s coming from the left.

    Sieg Heil
    (Characteristic of a cult of personality, it was adopted in the 1930s by the Nazi Party to signal obedience to the party’s leader )

  • Gary

    The original thread if anybody cares. I was playing last man standing with some real mindless Obamabots.

  • Pingback: Peggy Noonan: An American Crisis in Character | Born Conservative()

  • SeniorD

    Ms. Noonan is spot on regarding the content of her essay. America is rudderless in the sea of moral relativism permeating today’s society. As a culture, Americans have no clue as to the character of even ‘The Greatest Generation’.

    Considering the comments in this thread, ad hominem attacks on Ms. Noonan support her premise of no character.

    She’s thrown down the gauntlet – is anyone going to accept her challenge?

  • Winston Wolfe

    Well, it sure is a good thing we’ve got a calm, reasoned, experienced leader in the White House to help guide us through these times, huh.

  • Lemonaide

    What we’re seeing is trickle down ethics. Leadership sets the tone and standard for those not rooted in Chtistianity.

  • P. Aaron

    Senior D. We’ve been out here, those Americans that care about our country and have character. For so long, we’ve been told ‘character’ doesn’t matter. Only to find that it’s all that matters, we were made fun of and banished.

    Character has ALWAYS been a factor in preserving our Constitutionally limited government.

    We remember Noonan selling us out over Obama’s rhetoric. She got in on the ‘hope & change’ vibe and failed to EXAMINE Obama’s past, or his present.

    Because folks like Noonan wrote us off for DARING to question Obama’s words and past deeds. We hurl invective in herndirection. She left us, and any examination of Obama’s character in search of a Demi-god.

    Noonan needs to examine her own premises before she starts the roll call for the rest of us.

  • #11 Senor D Sorry for not hurrying to come, fetch, set, and heel Ms. Noonan’ homily. If not for the internet, everyday occurrances would rarely penetrate her orb. Sorry you RINOS need social conservaives every 4 yrs. or so, but that’s how it is. Favorite Noonan quote? “normal is overrated”. See you at the club, TaTa!

  • Dwayne the canoe guy

    The problem with 76% thinking we’re not in the right track is this, How many think the right track is turning around and how many think the right track is going in the same direction only faster? I talk to folks who say this country is on the wrong track because we gave a Tea Party and vocal conservatives.

    A poll like this means nothing unless you define “Right track”

  • James

    peggy noonan supported obama, the worst president in american history and she is responsible for him.

  • jt

    The TSA was created by the right wingnuts under Herr Bush. You can pretend whatever you’d like, a fact is a fact.

  • StrangernFiction

    She’s thrown down the gauntlet

    Peggy Noonan throwing down the gauntlet?

    If you say so.

  • ‘What’s terrible about this story is that for anyone who’s ever seen the Secret Service up close it’s impossible to believe. The Secret Service are the best of the best.’

    Not any more. The SS is now the best of the mediocre.

    ‘In New York the past week a big story has been about 16 public school teachers who can’t be fired even though they’ve acted unprofessionally. What does “unprofessionally” mean in New York? Sex with students, stalking students, and, in one case, standing behind a kid, simulating sex, and saying, “I’ll show you what gay is.”‘


    ‘The leveling or deterioration of public behavior has got to be worrying people who have enough years on them to judge with some perspective.

    Something seems to be going terribly wrong.’

    Oh yes, never before did an illegal immigrant like Hussein ever run for the presidency let alone get elected. That itself is terribly wrong and everything else flows from that.

  • Pingback: Peggy Noonan: An American Crisis in Character()

  • Pingback: Peggy Noonan: An American Crisis in Character | Liberal Whoppers()

  • Tom in CA

    A great majority of this started with Bill and Hill.

  • Patty

    This crisis could be averted in a small way. Even rape victims are question by a woman office. Now, we treat one another like animals. You can profile but you could have the decency to respect the varying personalities that each individual has.

    It is imperative that we should one another compassion and as equals. I could be that woman, I don’t want to be treated like that and I too could be walking in her shoes. I won’t fly ever again but I made up my mind long ago. Before all the impersonal and indecent way in which this government wishes to treat us. I do realize that National security is at stake but there must be a better way.

    We have become numb to a person’s feelings and this treatment of this woman will leave ever lasting scares. That is what they accomplish under the keeping the nation safe.

  • Fred

    Noonan has that charming-but-condescending way of talking about ‘other people’ in her little sermonettes while blithely skipping over her own rather large part in bringing it all about.

  • Andreas K.

    Juvenile crime happens, yes. But it’s getting worse, and that’s a simple fact. Crime in general is getting worse.

    10-20 years ago, car theft happened here in Austria. Burglaries happened. Today they happen every day. The news are full with them. It’s so bad that police in East Austria started up a task force to deal with car theft and burglaries and home intrusions are effectively happening every day.

    Same with the “flash robs”. This stuff hasn’t happened here yet, but it will. Groups of “youths” attacking pairs of other people is not unknown by now.

    Why is it happening? Well, the crime, at least here, is a result of stupid EU treaties (Schengen.) If you don’t protect your borders, anyone can enter, do whatever he wants and then leave again without anyone noticing. Same with youth crime. Why is it where it is? Because the penal system has been perverted and broken for decades by the left wing in the name if “humanity”. Prison in many EU countries is no longer a punishment, it’s vacation. Youth prisons in Austria are hotels. The criminal youths can even play modern games on computers in their own rooms.

    While the US may not have the EU, it certainly has its fair share of rabid leftists who scream “human rights” at everything, so your reasons for being where you are are basically the same as ours.

  • Gary Ogletree

    Peggy Noonan? Three years past her expiry date.

  • Rob De Witt

    See,and after WWII,they said,”It could never happen here”

    It can,it will and it does,happen here.
    Instead of coming from the right,it’s coming from the left.

    Sieg Heil
    (Characteristic of a cult of personality, it was adopted in the 1930s by the Nazi Party to signal obedience to the party’s leader )

    – ebayer @ 3:30

    FWIW, that novel (It Can’t Happen Here) was published in 1935 – or 10 years earlier than the period you describe. The author, Sinclair Lewis, did in fact believe that the danger would come from the Right, and of course equated Nazism with the Right Wing.

    Lewis was also, to no one’s surprise, a vociferous Leftie of the old-time-Minnesota-Socialist persuasion, of course.

    And btw. #6v MAC – plus about 10000. “Gyno-Marxism” is the phrase of the day.

  • stonedome

    obamadyke soldiers led by there commanderette janet nazipolitano

  • Patty

    TSA needs to be privatized. Government under Obama has shown little respect for America. That is my opinion. We went through on of the worst tragedies in our Nation besides Pearl Harbor on our soil.

    President Bush kept us safe whether is was skill or luck. We were not attacked. Under Obama he is going to the extremes as he doesn’t want to be in a position like 911 and hopefully he won’t because what he has done is complete failure with every thing else.

    So, we live under the rule of Janet and oh, fast and furious. More deaths have come out on that one. There mishandling of Fast and Furious is an example of complete dishonor and disrespect for innocents lives lost and for the Family of Brian Terry. And look at the GSA and Secret Service.

    They just do what they want and then when the S flies they run around like little mice and hide or blame Bush or some other Republican.

  • GP Fan

    Where the hell is GOP congress??? Don’t we have the right not to be illegally searched without probable cause??? DOES THE CONSTITUTION MEAN ANYTHING ANYMORE??? WHY DO WE EVEN HAVE IT???